Every era of Indianapolis Colts football, one lineup. These are the highest-rated Indianapolis Colts legends across the 1960s to today — a full 11 on both sides of the ball, chosen by iKnoBall's era-adjusted engine — and the record they'd post over a 17-game season.
Offense is weighted 55%, defense 45% — exactly how iKnoBall scores a roster. Think you'd start a different 11? Prove it.
Peyton Manning headlines the group at a 99 overall — the kind of number only genuine all-time greats reach on iKnoBall's scale. Around Manning, the model fills out a complete lineup that balances quarterback play, skill-position firepower, the trenches, and a defense across Indianapolis Colts history, then simulates all 17 games. The result — 14–3 — reflects both the raw talent and how the pieces fit on both sides of the ball.
Every Indianapolis Colts legend in the iKnoBall pool, ranked by era-adjusted overall. The top group forms the starting 11 above; the rest are the depth chart and the debate.
| Player | Position | Era | OVR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peyton Manning | Quarterback | 2000s | 99 |
| Eric Dickerson | Running Back | 1980s | 97 |
| Marvin Harrison | Wide Receiver | 2000s | 96 |
| Reggie Wayne | Wide Receiver | 2000s | 92 |
| Quenton Nelson | Offensive Guard | 2020s | 96 |
| Dwight Freeney | Defensive End | 2000s | 95 |
| Darius Leonard | Linebacker | 2020s | 93 |
| Vontae Davis | Cornerback | 2010s | 87 |
| Bob Sanders | Strong Safety | 2000s | 91 |
| Johnny Unitas | Quarterback | 1960s | 98 |
| Gino Marchetti | Defensive End | 1960s | 94 |
| Jim Parker | Offensive Guard | 1960s | 95 |
| Jonathan Taylor | Running Back | 2020s | 94 |
| John Mackey | Tight End | 1960s | 93 |
| Marshall Faulk | Running Back | 1990s | 93 |
| Edgerrin James | Running Back | 2000s | 93 |
| DeForest Buckner | Defensive Tackle | 2020s | 93 |
| Lenny Moore | Running Back | 1960s | 91 |
| Raymond Berry | Wide Receiver | 1960s | 91 |
| Jeff Saturday | Center | 2000s | 91 |
| Robert Mathis | Defensive End | 2000s | 91 |
| Andrew Luck | Quarterback | 2010s | 91 |
| T.Y. Hilton | Wide Receiver | 2010s | 90 |
| Bert Jones | Quarterback | 1970s | 87 |
| Dallas Clark | Tight End | 2000s | 87 |
| Tarik Glenn | Offensive Tackle | 2000s | 87 |
| Anthony Castonzo | Offensive Tackle | 2010s | 87 |
| Frank Gore | Running Back | 2010s | 87 |
| Michael Pittman Jr. | Wide Receiver | 2020s | 87 |
| Braden Smith | Offensive Tackle | 2020s | 87 |
Draft your own all-time Indianapolis Colts — or any franchise across five sports — build your roster, and sim a full season chasing a perfect 17–0. Free to play.
Build Your All-Time TeamGet the AppBy iKnoBall's era-adjusted ratings the all-time Indianapolis Colts lineup is Peyton Manning (QB, 2000s), Eric Dickerson (RB, 1980s), Marvin Harrison (WR1, 2000s), Reggie Wayne (WR2, 2000s), Quenton Nelson (OL, 2020s), Dwight Freeney (DL, 2000s), Darius Leonard (LB, 2020s), Vontae Davis (CB, 2010s), Bob Sanders (S, 2000s), Johnny Unitas (FLEX-O, 1960s), Gino Marchetti (FLEX-D, 1960s). Together they project to a 14–3 regular season.
iKnoBall's simulation projects this 11-man lineup at 14–3 over a 17-game season, with an average starter rating of 94. The model runs each game as a probability from the roster's combined offensive and defensive strength, so an all-time team contends for a near-perfect year but nothing is guaranteed.
Each player's overall is era-adjusted so a 1970s legend and a modern superstar sit on the same 70–99 scale. Offense (QB, skill players, line) is weighted 55% and defense 45%, and only true all-time greats reach the mid-to-high 90s.
Yes — iKnoBall is a free game where you draft one legend per era, build your all-time roster, and simulate a full season chasing a perfect 17–0. Play it free at play.iknoball.com.
All-Time Football · All-Time Basketball · Play iKnoBall · About · Privacy
Ratings are era-adjusted and computed by iKnoBall's simulation engine. Records are model projections for entertainment, not predictions. Player names belong to their respective owners; iKnoBall is an independent fan-made game.